Throwback: When Former PM Manmohan Singh Attended Iftar Party Hosted by Then CJI Balakrishnan

New Delhi: Amid the ongoing row over Prime Minister Narendra Modi attending the Ganpati Puja celebrations at Chief Justice of India (CJI) DY Chandrachud’s residence, a throwback photo of former PM Manmohan Singh attending an Iftaar party hosted by then CJI, KG Balakrishnan started doing rounds on social media. Several BJP leaders have also shared the photo wherein Singh can be seen sharing a candid laugh with Balakrishnan.  

“2009- PM Manmohan Singh's Iftaar Party was attended by then CJI KG Balakrishnan- Sshhhh - Yeh Secular hai.. judiciary is safe! PM Modi attends Ganesh Puja at current CJI House - oh God Judiciary compromised”, BJP leader Shehzad Poonawalla mocked the Congress in his post.

How The Controversy Started?

A massive controversy erupted after Prime Minister Modi participated in the Ganpati Puja at the CJI's residence. In a video, Chandrachud and his wife Kalpana Das were seen welcoming Modi at their house. Several opposition leaders and some lawyers of the Supreme Court reacted sharply to Modi attending the puja at the CJI's residence.

"Ganpati Utsav is being celebrated and people visit each other's house... I don't have information whether the prime minister has visited anyone's house," Shiv Sena (UBT) leader Sanjay Raut said.

"However, the prime minister visited the CJI's residence. They performed 'aarti' together. We think that people will have doubts if guardians of the Constitution meet political leaders," Raut added.

In a post on X, senior lawyer Indira Jaising said the Chief Justice of India has compromised the separation of powers between the executive and the judiciary. "Lost all confidence in the independence of the CJI. The SCBA (Supreme Court Bar Association) must condemn this publicly displayed compromise of Independence of the CJI from the executive," she said in her post.

Can't different pillars of democracy meet, and converge, shouldn't they be friends?

Reacting sharply to the comments, BJP spokesperson Patra said, "There are some silly sold out so-called seculars who will object to such kind of courtesy visits but the maturity of this great democracy is tall enough to bypass this kind of immature and childish talks taking place right now in Indian politics." He said Prime Minister Modi and the CJI's courtesy meeting reflects the "beauty of democracy" and it makes India better than other countries.

"What do they want? Can't different pillars of democracy meet, and converge, shouldn't they be friends? Should they be enemies? Should they not not be talking to each other? Shouldn't they not extend a handshake? Shouldnt they have courtesies extended towards each other?" Patra asked.

Slamming the critics, BJP national general secretary (Organisation) BL Santhosh said though left liberals have started crying over the prime minister attending the event at the CJI's residence, "it was not socialising but a devoted Ganapathi Pooja". "Started crying! Civility, cordiality, togetherness, co-travellers in nations journey are all an anathema to these left liberals. Also it was not socialising but a devoted Ganapathi Pooja is very hard to digest. SCBA is not a moral compass. Take a deep breath once," Santhosh said in a post on X reacting to Jaising's comments.

‘Reckless commentary’

Shiv Sena Rajya Sabha MP Milind Deora also flayed the critics and said it's unfortunate to see "reckless commentary" on Prime Minister Modi's visit to the CJI's residence for Ganapati Aarti.

"When verdicts favour them, the opposition praises the Supreme Court's credibility, but when things don't go their way, they conveniently claim the judiciary is compromised," he charged in a post on X.

Casting such baseless aspersions on the highest court sets a dangerous precedent, he added. "This reckless attempt to undermine the credibility of the CJI by the opposition is not only irresponsible but also damaging to the institution's integrity. India's politics is taking an ugly turn," Deora said.

The era of "arbitrary judicial appointments" is long gone and the incumbent CJI has served his office with immense integrity, he added. "Those seeking to tarnish his legacy and credibility are showing poor judgment and acting against the nation's best interests," Deora added.