'Unworkable Approach': Delhi HC Rejects 'Complete Ban on Mobile Phones' in Schools, Sets New Guidelines

New Delhi: The Delhi High Court on Monday (March 3) rejected the idea of imposing a complete ban on smartphones in schools, calling such an approach "undesirable and unworkable."

The court instead emphasised teaching students "responsible digital behaviour" and set out new guidelines for them. These guidelines are aimed at regulating the use of smartphones by pupils, balancing the advantages of technology with the potential risks associated with excessive screen time and misuse.

Also read | Supreme Court Dismisses Plea For Recalling TN Governor Over Assembly Walkout

Justice Anup Jairam Bhambhani, delivering the judgment, observed that the role of technology in education has evolved significantly over the past few years, making an outright ban on smartphones 'unrealistic.' He emphasised that smartphones play an essential role in keeping students connected with their parents, contributing to their safety and security.

This development comes as the case was brought before the court following a dispute involving a minor student who had misused a smartphone at a Delhi School.

In response, the school took strict disciplinary action. During the proceedings, the school requested the court to establish a clear set of guidelines for smartphone use in schools.

However, while acknowledging the potential harms of smartphones, including their misuse, addiction, and their role in exacerbating issues like cyberbullying and anxiety, the court ruled that instead of a blanket ban, schools should adopt a policy of responsible usage.

Justice Bhambhani noted that such policies should not stifle the positive uses of smartphones but ensure they do not disrupt the educational environment.

"As a matter of policy, students should not be barred from carrying smartphones to school, but the use of smartphones in school must be regulated and monitored. Where it is possible to make arrangements for the safekeeping of smartphones, students should be required to deposit their smartphones when they enter school and take them back when returning home," HC directed.

Also read | Former AG Misused Office But Will Not Arrest Him For Now: Chhattisgarh Tells Supreme Court

Key Guidelines for Smartphone Use in Schools

Here are the key guidelines issued by the court for use of smartphones in schools:

• Where possible, students should deposit their smartphones upon entering the school and retrieve them at the end of the day.
• Smartphones should not be used in classrooms, common areas, or school vehicles to avoid disruptions.
• Students should use smartphones for connectivity, safety, but not for entertainment.
• Schools must educate students on responsible online behavior, digital manners, and the ethical use of smartphones. Students must be made aware of the risks associated with excessive screen time, including reduced attention spans, increased anxiety, and exposure to cyberbullying.
• Policies should be ruled out with suitable inputs from parents and teachers.
• In cases of misuse, schools may confiscate smartphones as a disciplinary measure.

This decision by the Delhi High Court comes at a time when the use of smartphones in schools has become a growing concern, especially with the increasing integration of technology into education. The court’s ruling provides a balanced approach that allows students to benefit from the advantages of connectivity and safety, while minimising the risks associated with their misuse.